Star Wars Has Always Been Controversial

If you haven’t already, follow Mike Klimo (@MikeKlimo), author of “Star Wars: The Ring Theory,” on Twitter. One of the things he’s been doing lately is posting excerpts of not-so-fawning reviews and essays about ANH, TESB, and ROTJ.

A lot of what he has posted is familiar to me. As a little kid, I didn’t read movie reviews and when TESB came out, I’d only read the local paper’s review (The Miami Herald) which was basically a three-star review. When ROTJ was released, I was exposed to more reviews and it was only then that I was aware of a critical/media backlash. I remember sitting there plowing through breakfast before school and booing the t.v. as Gene Shalit ripped on the film on the “Today” show. I remember reading that summer in South Florida magazine or some such a really nasty essay that took no prisoners. My suspicions at the time were that these people were cranks, they were jealous and resented the saga’s success, and they were quite possibly a bunch of no-good Commies.

When I was in college, I would hang around the huge library between classes where it was more convenient to wait than to hike all of the way back to the dorm and then having to hike all of the way back to the main part of campus an hour later. So I would do stuff like look up old articles and reviews of the saga in various publication collections and even on microfilm. Hey, I was just maintaining my research skills! I was shocked to discover it wasn’t just a small group of cranks who had decided to gang up on ROTJ because Star Wars had become too popular. There were people who never liked ANY of the films. Even the positive reviews rarely if ever had anything good to say about performances beyond that of Sir Alec Guinness. A lot of them went along the lines of, “In spite of the corny dialogue and stiff acting, (insert title) was a fun time at the matinee!” The visual effects easily got far more praise than any of the acting, direction, or dialogue.

It was the beginning of the realization that Star Wars had always been regarded very differently from other “serious cinema” with the rare exception of populist movie critics like Roger Ebert and whatever value many critics found in ANH it seemed to have worn thin with TESB and ROTJ. I’d even go as far to say many critics didn’t get into Star Wars the way many audiences did. It was rare to find genuine affection for the characters or appreciation for the films’ mythic cycle. I remember one guy writing that he was glad to finally be rid of that “whiny Luke, smarmy Han, and bitchy Leia.” Ouch! I also do not recall a single critic considering TESB the best of the series.

When someone comes along with something new, different, refreshing, unique, etc., it seems to me the critics and the media just love it. Then it becomes phenomenally successful and every follow up is either unfairly measured against the effect of its predecessor or viewed as cynical cash grab. Then they start to question why it was ever a phenomenon in the first place, taking the position it never deserved that kind of success. It seems to me Star Wars has long since fallen victim to that way of thinking, years before the prequels ever came out. What happened was in the ‘90s with Gen X-ers becoming more prominent in the media, the advent of the internet, and the growth of “geek culture,” Eps IV-VI finally got put on the critical pedestal. Especially TESB. People who had loved the movies almost unconditionally as kids took them much more seriously and there was finally an appreciation for what they had accomplished. Maybe it wasn’t universal, not even by the time the Special Editions came out, but the turnaround in critical opinion was thrilling to me at the time.

Unfortunately that pedestal was a little too high and that definitely contributed to the inflated expectations heaped upon the prequels, which couldn’t live up to the legend these guys had built up around the first set of films. Strangely enough, virtually every criticism ever leveled at ANH, TESB, and ROTJ was again leveled at TPM, AOTC, and ROTS. It’s as though this new generation of fans, geeks, and critics turned into the ones of old without their realizing it, only they were far less literate than their predecessors.

This entry was posted in fandom and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Star Wars Has Always Been Controversial

  1. Keith Palmer says:

    I’m not on Twitter myself (inertia, mostly; maybe I’d get better at “witty telegraphese” if I tried), but I’ve at least been able to “lurk” on Mike Klimo’s tweets there (while facing a certain sense of how ephemeral everything on that platform feels). I’d known before critical reaction to the “old trilogy” wasn’t uniformly positive (having done just a little bit of digging into old records myself), but I’ve at least found some amusement in some of the more seemingly knee-jerk reactions to TESB.

    In thinking a bit about it, though, I did get to worrying that where the critics of the 1980s at least said their piece and moved on, today’s “aggrieved fanboys” simply can’t let go even as they manage to keep convincing less obsessed people they’re the “real fans” and their perspectives count the most of all. If the ancillary merchandising going away in the second half of the 1980s somehow helped fonder perspectives take over, then maybe there will come a time when someone will look back and say the current soft-balling of the new movies gave them a necessary bit of space. I’m also worried, however, that we may have to count on the current cycle somehow running its course and the whole franchise winding up “in the vault.”


    • lazypadawan says:

      And it would be really unfortunate if that’s what it takes.


    • Marshall says:

      Sadly, many of these “aggrieved fanboys” aren’t just random commenters on websites, they’re in positions of power and run sites like, Barnes and Noble Sci Fi and Fantasy blog,,, etc. that keep fanning the flames of hate. How ironic that Simon Pegg (of all people) worried that our current obsession of anything “geeky” is making us “childish”.


      • Bob Clark says:

        Yeah. He’s like a non self-conscious version of a mad scientist at the end of a movie. “Dear God! What have everybody-other-than-me done?!?”


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s